Misusing the Market Prices of High-Vote Shares When Estimating a Discount for Lack of Voting Rights
When analysts estimate a valuation discount for the lack of voting rights in the stock of a private company, they typically look to the public market. Many studies have compared the market prices of publicly traded high-vote shares with the market prices of publicly traded low-vote shares. Unfortunately, when the inputs into these studies are examined, the emperor has no clothes.
Reader Question: How Much Is a Discount for Lack of Voting Rights?
In response to a reader question, we put the BVResearch Pro platform to work to reveal what the studies, valuation textbooks, and court cases say about a discount for nonvoting stock—more than enough material to estimate and substantiate an opinion.
Manipulation of Valuation of Bequeathed Stock Sinks Charitable Contribution Claim
Tax Court says executor of estate in series of post-death measures changed the value and size of decedent’s stock donation and may not claim date-of-death value of assets not actually transferred to family foundation; court affirms estate tax deficiency.
Estate of Dieringer v. Commissioner
Tax Court says executor of estate in series of post-death measures changed the value and size of decedent’s stock donation and may not claim date-of-death value of assets not actually transferred to family foundation; court affirms estate tax deficiency.
Court Judges Assessment of Risk Factors, Marketability Discount Evidence
The issue in this consolidated case was the fair market value of two minority nonvoting stock interests in Schwan's Sales Enterprises Inc. (SSE), one as of Dec. 31, 1992 (date of gift) and the other as of Dec. 31, 1994 (date of charitable contribution).
Okerlund v. United States (I)
The issue in this consolidated case was the fair market value of two minority nonvoting stock interests in Schwan's Sales Enterprises, Inc.
Estate of Schwan v. Commissioner
At issue is the valuation of the decedent's stock in a closely-held corporation for purposes of computing the gross estate and the allowable charitable deduction under Federal tax laws.
Redemption Agreement Did Not Affect Value of Decedent's Estate
The petitioners in this case, decedent's estate and a charitable foundation (the Martin M. Schwan Foundation), challenged the IRS' determination that the estate had a tax deficiency based on a bequest to the foundation and that the foundation was liable as a transferee.
Estate of Winkler v. Commissioner
Tax Court provides guidance on report writing to avoid “random walk approach” and finds respondent’s expert failed to detail thought processes underlying valuation conclusions in appraisal report.